Crumbl Review: S’mores Skillet Cookie ft. Hershey’s Chocolate

This is one of those cookies where the expectation is very clear — it needs to taste like a s’more. Not just chocolate and marshmallow thrown together, but that actual layered experience you get when you’re making one over a fire. And when it’s done right, it’s one of the best flavour profiles Crumbl does.

The base of this cookie leans more toward a graham-style cookie, which is exactly what you want here. It’s slightly sweet, a little bit crumbly, but still soft enough to hold everything together. It doesn’t overpower anything — it acts as that foundation that lets the chocolate and marshmallow stand out.

The marshmallow element is a big part of this cookie, and it’s done well. It’s soft, slightly gooey, and gives that melted feel without turning into a mess. You don’t get that overly sticky, hard-to-eat texture — it stays controlled, which makes the whole cookie easier to enjoy.

Then there’s the Hershey’s chocolate, which is a key detail. Hershey’s has a very specific flavour — sweeter and smoother than darker chocolates — and it fits perfectly here. It gives that authentic s’mores taste instead of turning it into just another chocolate cookie.

Texture is where this one really shines. You’ve got the soft cookie base, the slightly gooey marshmallow, and the smoother chocolate all working together. Nothing feels out of place, and you actually get a bit of everything in each bite.

What I like about this cookie is that it feels complete. It doesn’t rely too heavily on one element — everything plays its role, and it actually delivers on the idea it’s based on.

Final Verdict:

A really solid s’mores cookie that actually tastes like a s’more. Balanced, textured, and one of the stronger options of the week.