Copycat Crumbl Ultimate Peanut Butter Cookie

This one is a bit more straightforward compared to the doughnut, but it still leans into that same chocolate-heavy idea. Visually, it looks like a standard bakery cookie, just loaded with chocolate pieces. Nothing overly fancy, but you can tell what you’re getting. The first bite is soft and slightly chewy. It has that typical…

Warm, spiced, and maple-kissed — the French Toast Cookie brings cozy brunch energy to dessert. Buttery cookie base, maple glaze, and cinnamon sugar make this one of the most comforting flavors Crumbl’s ever done. 🧈 Ingredients Cookie Base ½ cup unsalted butter, softened ½ cup brown sugar ¼ cup granulated sugar 1 egg 1 tsp…

This is a sweet, cozy, dessert-like matcha drink that tastes exactly like a frosted sugar cookie. Soft, smooth, sweet, and creamy — and the matcha sits quietly in the background. Ingredients (1 drink) Sugar Cookie Syrup: ¼ cup white sugar ¼ cup brown sugar ½ cup water 1 tsp vanilla extract ¼ tsp almond extract…

Rich vanilla base, cake-like crumb, and frosting that tastes like buttercream on a cupcake. Ingredients: 1 cup butter 1 cup sugar 2 eggs 1 tsp almond extract (optional, for “birthday cake” vibe) 2 ½ cups flour 1 tsp baking powder ½ tsp salt ½ cup rainbow sprinkles Frosting: ½ cup butter 2 ½ cups powdered…

This one is very clearly built around recreating that classic brown sugar cinnamon Pop-Tart flavour, which is already a strong and recognizable profile. The goal here is to take that flavour and translate it into a cookie, and for the most part, it does exactly that. The base of the cookie is soft, slightly thick,…

This one is immediately in that heavier, dessert-style category. Cheesecake alone already leans rich, and when you add caramel into the mix, it has the potential to either balance really well or become too much. The base acts like a graham-style crust again, soft but slightly structured. It gives that subtle cookie foundation without pulling…