Crumbl Review: Buckeye Brownie Cookie
This one is very clearly built around that classic chocolate and peanut butter combination. If you know buckeyes, you already know what you’re getting — rich chocolate with a strong peanut butter presence.
The base is that familiar brownie-style cookie again. It’s soft, dense, and fudgy, leaning much closer to a brownie than a traditional cookie. It gives you that rich chocolate foundation right away.
The peanut butter is the main flavour here. It’s smooth, slightly thick, and comes through strongly in every bite. It’s not subtle at all — it’s meant to stand out.
The chocolate base supports it well, but it definitely takes a back seat to the peanut butter. The combination still works because chocolate and peanut butter naturally complement each other, but this cookie leans heavily toward the peanut butter side.
Texture is a mix of soft brownie and creamy topping, which keeps everything cohesive. There’s not much contrast, but the flavour combination carries it.
This is definitely one of the heavier cookies of the week. It’s rich, filling, and very flavour-forward, so it’s something you’d likely eat in smaller portions.
Final Verdict:
A very peanut butter-forward brownie cookie. Rich, heavy, and exactly what you’d expect from a buckeye-style dessert.