Crumbl Review: Mallow Cream Cookie ft. Lucky Charms
This one leans heavily into that fun, nostalgic category right away. Between the marshmallow base and the Lucky Charms topping, it’s clearly designed to feel more like a childhood treat than a traditional cookie.
The base is soft and slightly thicker, with that smooth, almost melt-in-your-mouth texture. It doesn’t have a super strong flavour on its own, which actually works because the topping is doing most of the work here.
The marshmallow cream is the main element. It’s sweet, fluffy, and very smooth, giving the cookie that light, airy feel rather than something dense. It leans sweet, but not in a heavy way.
Then you have the Lucky Charms pieces, which bring both flavour and texture. You get that classic cereal sweetness along with the crunch from the cereal bits and the slight firmness of the marshmallows.
What makes this cookie work is the contrast. The soft base and cream paired with the crunch from the cereal keeps it from feeling flat.
Flavour-wise, it’s very much what you’d expect — sweet, cereal-forward, and a bit playful. It’s not trying to be complex, it’s just meant to be enjoyable.
This is definitely one of those cookies that leans more toward the “experience” side rather than depth of flavour.
Final Verdict:
A fun, nostalgic cookie with great texture contrast. Sweet, playful, and easy to enjoy.