Crumbl Review: Key Lime Pie Cookie
This one stands out right away just because it’s so different from the rest of the lineup.
The base is more like a graham-style cookie, and you immediately get that slightly crumbly, buttery texture that mimics a pie crust. It’s not overly sweet, which is important because the topping carries most of the flavour.
On top, you get the key lime filling, which is where everything really comes together. It’s creamy, smooth, and has that tangy citrus hit that cuts through the sweetness perfectly.
The balance here is the key. The lime is noticeable, but not sharp or sour to the point where it’s too much. It sits right in that middle ground where it’s refreshing but still dessert-like.
There’s usually some kind of whipped topping or lighter element added, which helps soften everything and gives it that full “pie” feel rather than just a cookie with flavouring.
Texture-wise, it’s a really nice mix — slightly crumbly base, smooth filling, and light topping.
This is one of those cookies that feels lighter than it actually is, just because of the citrus.
Final Verdict:
A fresh, balanced cookie that actually captures the feel of key lime pie. Tangy, creamy, and a nice break from heavier flavours.