Crumbl Weekly Review Mar 16-22
This week is a really interesting mix because it leans heavily into two categories: nostalgia and balance.
You’ve got cookies like the Mallow Cream ft. Lucky Charms and Cereal Milk, which are clearly built around that childhood cereal idea. They’re fun, sweet, and more about the experience than deep flavour complexity. Between the two, the Lucky Charms cookie stands out more because of the texture contrast and stronger flavour, while the cereal milk cookie plays it safer and more subtle.
Then you move into the richer side with the Andes Mint Brownie, which brings in that dense, chocolate-heavy profile. It’s easily one of the more filling cookies this week and definitely caters to people who want something heavier and more indulgent.
The Key Lime Pie Cookie breaks that pattern completely. It’s lighter, more refreshing, and one of the best-balanced cookies this week. The citrus cuts through everything and gives you a break from the heavier chocolate and sugar-forward options.
Finally, the St. Patrick’s Celebration Cake Cookie rounds everything out with a very classic, frosting-focused option. It doesn’t try to stand out flavour-wise, but it delivers exactly what it’s supposed to — a sweet, cake-like treat.
What really stands out this week is the range. You’re not getting six versions of the same thing — you’re getting:
- nostalgic cereal cookies
- rich chocolate dessert
- citrus-based lighter option
- classic cake-style cookie
That variety makes the week feel more complete and less repetitive.
If there’s a downside, it’s that a couple of the cookies lean a bit safe or expected — nothing here is wildly experimental. But at the same time, everything is executed well within its category.
Top Picks:
- Key Lime Pie Cookie (best balance + uniqueness)
- Andes Mint Brownie (best for richness)
- Mallow Cream ft. Lucky Charms (most fun / nostalgic)
More Middle Ground:
- Cereal Milk (good but subtle)
- Celebration Cake (solid but expected)
Overall:
This is a very approachable, well-rounded week. Nothing feels like a miss, but a few stand out more depending on what you’re in the mood for.