Crumbl Review: Snickers Peanut Butter Cookie
This one is exactly what it sounds like — and that’s both a good thing and something to be aware of going in.
Visually, it looks loaded. You’ve got a thick cookie base with visible mix-ins, usually chunks that mimic that Snickers combination of chocolate, peanut butter, and caramel. It immediately looks heavy.
The first bite confirms that.
The peanut butter hits first. It’s strong, slightly salty, and gives the cookie a dense, rich base.
Then the chocolate comes in, followed by the caramel element, which adds a softer sweetness and a bit of chew.
That combination is what carries the cookie:
- peanut butter adds depth
- chocolate adds richness
- caramel adds sweetness and texture
The balance is decent, but it definitely leans heavy. There’s no real “light” element to break things up.
Texture is layered:
- dense cookie base
- soft caramel sections
- occasional chunks of chocolate
It keeps things interesting, but it’s still a lot overall.
This is not a casual cookie. It’s filling, rich, and something you either split or take your time with.
It does what it’s supposed to do, but it doesn’t try to go beyond that.
Final Verdict:
Rich, dense, and very peanut butter-forward. Good flavour combination, but heavy and best in smaller portions.