Crumbl Review: Peanut Butter Cup Skillet Cookie ft. Reese’s
This one is built to be indulgent, and it doesn’t try to hide that at all.
Visually, it’s thick and served more like a skillet dessert than a cookie. It looks dense, with melted chocolate and peanut butter elements throughout, often with Reese’s pieces on top.
The first bite is heavy right away.
The peanut butter hits first — strong, slightly salty, and very rich. It sets the tone for the entire cookie.
Then the chocolate comes in, followed by the Reese’s pieces, which add both sweetness and texture.
That combination gives you:
- peanut butter depth
- chocolate richness
- small bursts of sweetness from Reese’s
The issue is balance.
There’s nothing really cutting through the richness. No tartness, no light element — just:
👉 rich → richer → consistent
Texture:
- dense, soft center
- melted chocolate pockets
- slight crunch from candy pieces
It’s definitely satisfying, but it’s also one of the heaviest items.
This is something you eat slowly, not casually.
Final Verdict:
Very rich and peanut butter-heavy. Good flavour combination, but leans too heavy to feel balanced.