Review: Crumbl Pumpkin Cake Cookie
Pumpkin season always brings big expectations, and Crumbl’s Pumpkin Cake Cookie aims to deliver a slice of fall in cookie form.
First Impressions
Golden pumpkin cookie, cream cheese frosting, and chocolate chip topping. It’s festive, it’s indulgent, and it smells like autumn.
Flavor Notes
The pumpkin cake base is rich, moist, and perfectly spiced—it really does taste like pumpkin cake. The topping adds creaminess without overwhelming. The chocolate chips, however, feel unnecessary. They don’t ruin the cookie, but they don’t add much either.
Texture & Balance
Soft and cake-like with the right amount of frosting. The flavors mesh well, and the pumpkin shines.
Bottom Line
This cookie delivers what it promises: pumpkin cake in cookie form. The chocolate chips are odd but forgettable. Overall, a fall win that feels seasonal and satisfying.