Crumbl Weekly Lineup Overview September 14-20

This week’s Crumbl lineup feels like a bit of a mixed bag — some strong hits that shine for their creativity and balance, and a couple that don’t quite live up to their potential. It’s a week that offers something for everyone, but not every cookie is going to win you over.

Standout Winners

The Raspberry Cupcake is the undeniable star. Crumbl nailed the fruit flavor, delivering a vibrant, tangy raspberry that balances perfectly with the creamy frosting. It’s bold without being artificial and easily one of their best fruit-inspired cookies.

Right alongside it is the S’mores Skillet, which captures the nostalgia of a campfire treat almost perfectly. Between the graham base, gooey marshmallow, and melty chocolate, this one feels like a cozy, indulgent win.

Solid Comforts

The Chocolate Milkshake is another strong showing — simple but effective. It’s smooth, creamy, and delivers exactly what the name promises. It may not be the most exciting of the lineup, but it’s one of the easiest to love.

The Cake Batter Blondie fits into this category too. While it leans a little plain — more like a sweet vanilla cookie with sprinkles than anything truly “cake batter” — it’s still a safe, enjoyable bite. It’s the kind of cookie you wouldn’t go out of your way for but wouldn’t mind if it showed up in a box.

Hit-or-Miss Options

The Cinnamon Roll Cheesecake is where things get a little tricky. It’s delicious, yes, but it doesn’t feel like a cookie at all. This one is a fork-and-plate dessert, rich with cream cheese and light on the cinnamon roll. Cheesecake lovers will adore it, but if you came for cookie texture, you’ll be let down.

Then there’s the Dark Dream, which caters squarely to dark chocolate purists. It’s bold, bitter, and rich, but for anyone who prefers sweeter chocolate, it borders on overwhelming. It’s one of those divisive cookies that’s either a hit or a pass depending on your chocolate preference.

Final Thoughts

Overall, this week’s Crumbl box has variety — you’ve got fruity, chocolatey, nostalgic, and decadent options all at once. The Raspberry Cupcake and S’mores Skillet carry the lineup, with the Chocolate Milkshake rounding out the dependable middle ground. The rest are more niche, catering to specific cravings rather than broad appeal.

If you’re looking to order this week, go in knowing what you love — because the hits are worth it, but the misses are easy to skip.