Crumbl Weekly Lineup Overview September 7-13
This week’s Crumbl menu was an adventurous one. It mixed classic dessert flavors with creative twists, plus the Electric Storm Drink that definitely stole attention. The result was a lineup that offered something bold, something sweet, and a little something seasonal.
The Showstopper
The Electric Storm Drink was hands down the most unique item of the week. The fizz of the Sprite paired with the tang of blue raspberry syrup gave it a sharp, punchy base, while the coconut cream softened it into something creamy and smooth. The flavor leaned more into blue raspberry than coconut, but that worked in its favor. It felt like a grown-up take on a childhood soda, and it was surprisingly well balanced — sweet, fizzy, and fun without being cloying.
The Chocolate-Forward Picks
The Brownie Batter Cookie was exactly what it promised: fudgy, gooey, and rich. The texture hit that sweet spot between chewy cookie and gooey brownie, while bits of brownie folded into the dough made it feel indulgent. On the other hand, the Cookies & Cream Cake leaned heavy on the chocolate side of the balance — so much so that the “cookies and cream” angle felt lost, and it came across more like just a chocolate cake. It wasn’t bad, but the cookies and cream identity didn’t shine.
Creamy, Sweet Staples
The Confetti Milkshake Cookie was a vanilla lover’s dream. Sweet, chewy, and covered with sprinkles, it looked the part and tasted simple but satisfying. The “milkshake” idea didn’t come through strongly — more sugar cookie with sprinkles than anything creamy or drink-inspired — but it was fun and nostalgic.
The Salted Caramel Cheesecake Cookie was rich and heavy. The graham-flavored base was tasty, but it dominated the cookie, overshadowing the caramel and cheesecake layers. For caramel fans, it might be a little disappointing, but for anyone who loves graham flavor, it worked.
Fruity Twists
The Strawberry Ice Cream Bar Cookie was a creative surprise. With a creamy frosting layer and crunchy topping, it really did capture the vibe of a classic strawberry ice cream bar. That said, the strawberry flavor could have been stronger — it leaned more on the creamy and vanilla side — but the concept was fun, and it looked great.
The Pumpkin Cake Cookie brought in seasonal flair. Moist, spiced, and topped like a mini pumpkin dessert, it captured the cozy pumpkin cake feel perfectly. The oddball was the chocolate chips baked in — they didn’t really add anything, but luckily they didn’t distract either.
Final Thoughts
This was a week of fun experiments. The Electric Storm Drink stood out as the highlight, with the Pumpkin Cake anchoring the seasonal side and the Brownie Batter Cookie offering classic chocolate comfort. Some, like the Cookies & Cream Cake and Salted Caramel Cheesecake, felt unbalanced or not quite true to their names, but they still had enjoyable moments.
If you like variety and don’t mind a lineup that takes risks, this week was worth the try — though a couple of the items leaned more novelty than “must order again.”