Crumbl Review: French Toast Cookie
The French Toast Cookie is one of those flavors that sounds like it might be too sweet — but it isn’t. It’s warm, cozy, and perfectly balanced between maple syrup sweetness and buttery comfort.
From the start, it looks homey — golden brown cookie, glossy drizzle, and that light dusting of cinnamon sugar that makes it smell like brunch. The aroma alone makes you want to grab a coffee and settle in.
The first bite hits with warm maple and buttery cinnamon — exactly like a plate of French toast fresh off the griddle. The frosting is smooth and creamy, with that maple-cinnamon blend that makes it rich but not heavy. The cookie base is soft, almost cake-like, with a little chew that keeps it grounded.
What makes it shine is the balance — it’s sweet but rounded, cozy but still bright. It’s the kind of cookie that feels like comfort food, perfect for chilly mornings or evenings when you want something that tastes like home.
Every element — from the cinnamon to the glaze — works together instead of competing. It’s simple, but it’s perfected simplicity.
I’d absolutely buy this one again. It’s the kind of cookie that makes you want to light a candle, put on a sweater, and just enjoy being cozy.