Crumbl Review: Candy Cane Brownie Cookie
This one is very clearly built around contrast — rich chocolate and cool peppermint — and it’s one of those combinations that either hits perfectly or feels completely off depending on how it’s balanced. Going into it, the expectation is basically a holiday brownie in cookie form, and for the most part, that’s exactly what it delivers.
The base of this cookie is where it really shines. It leans heavily into that brownie-style texture — soft, dense, slightly fudgy, and rich without being overly heavy. It doesn’t crumble like a traditional cookie, and it doesn’t feel dry at all. It has that smooth, almost melt-in-your-mouth consistency that makes it feel more like a dessert than just a cookie.
Flavour-wise, the chocolate is strong but not overwhelming. It’s deep and rich, but it doesn’t push into bitter territory, which is important because once peppermint is added, you don’t want the two competing too aggressively.
The candy cane element is noticeable but controlled. It comes through more as a cool, refreshing layer rather than a sharp mint hit. You get that slight crunch from the candy pieces, which adds texture, but the flavour itself doesn’t overpower the chocolate — it complements it.
That’s really what makes this cookie work. The peppermint isn’t trying to steal the show, and the chocolate isn’t trying to bury it. They actually meet in the middle, which is exactly what this kind of cookie needs.
Texture-wise, the contrast is solid. You’ve got the soft brownie base paired with small bits of crunch from the candy cane topping, which keeps it from feeling too one-note.
Overall, it leans rich but still feels seasonal and a bit lighter because of that peppermint freshness.
Final Verdict:
A really strong holiday cookie. The chocolate and peppermint are balanced well, and the brownie texture makes it feel more like a full dessert than just a cookie.