Crumbl Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie Review
The first look at this cookie is fun — a rich, dark chocolate base with a generous swirl of frosting and a cookie piece perched on top. It’s got that “extra” Crumbl presentation that makes it feel like a treat before you even take a bite.
Biting in, though, it’s clear this one is all about the peanut butter. The chocolate base exists, but once the frosting hits, the peanut butter dominates everything. Any hint of cocoa or balance is gone; what you’re left with is basically pure peanut butter flavor. That’s not necessarily bad if you’re a peanut butter person — but if you were hoping for a back-and-forth with chocolate, it’s not here.
The texture is classic Crumbl: soft and chewy, dense enough to feel indulgent but not so heavy it’s a chore. Still, one bite in and you know this is going to be rich. For me, one cookie was more than enough, and even one bite felt like I’d gotten the full experience.
Would I get it again? Personally, no. I like peanut butter, but I need a little more contrast or depth to keep me coming back. But for diehard peanut butter lovers — the ones who want everything in one bite — this cookie will absolutely hit the spot.