Crumbl Pumpkin Pie Cookie Review
This cookie is essentially a pumpkin pie in miniature form—golden crust, creamy orange filling, dollop of whipped topping—but it walks a fine line between brilliance and imbalance.
The filling is incredible: silky smooth, perfectly spiced with cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove. It captures that true pumpkin-pie flavor effortlessly. The problem lies beneath it. The crust base is thick and slightly dry, stealing focus from the luscious center. You find yourself wishing for more filling with every bite.
Still, the taste makes up for the textural quirk. Each spoon-less mouthful feels nostalgic, like Thanksgiving on a sugar-cookie base. When eaten chilled, the flavors blend beautifully—the spices mellow, and the sweetness deepens.
It’s a cookie that succeeds on flavor, even if structure holds it back. For pumpkin fans, though, that rich spiced filling alone makes it worth a repeat.