Crumbl Review: Chocolate Peanut Butter Brownie ft. Reese’s Pieces
If you love chocolate and peanut butter, this cookie is basically heaven. The Chocolate Peanut Butter Brownie ft. Reese’s Pieces is dense, rich, and absolutely packed with flavor — it’s like a brownie, a cookie, and a Reese’s all baked into one.
It looks gorgeous right out of the box: glossy dark chocolate cookie base, thick peanut butter swirl, and Reese’s Pieces scattered like confetti on top. It’s colorful but classy, indulgent but familiar.
The first bite? A perfect hit of contrast. The chocolate is deep and fudgy, leaning more dark than sweet, while the peanut butter adds that nutty creaminess that smooths everything out. The candy bits bring crunch and that unmistakable Reese’s flavor.
What makes it great is the texture. Crumbl nailed the balance between soft and chewy here — you get that dense brownie feel without it being too cakey or too rich. The peanut butter frosting is thick and salty-sweet, which keeps it from feeling one-note.
It’s intense, but in the best way — bold, satisfying, and exactly what you want when you’re craving a chocolate-peanut butter hit. You can’t stop at one bite, but you probably won’t need a second cookie — it’s that filling.
Would I get it again? Without hesitation. It’s easily one of Crumbl’s best chocolate-based cookies, and if you love Reese’s, it’s a must-try.