Crumbl Review: Cookies & Cream Sandwich Cookie
Any time Crumbl does a sandwich cookie, expectations go up a bit because now it’s not just about the cookie — it’s about how the filling and both sides work together. And with cookies & cream, there’s a very specific flavour people expect, so it really comes down to balance.
The cookie itself is soft, slightly dense, and very chocolate-forward. It has that classic Oreo-style flavour — not too dark, not too bitter — just smooth and sweet enough to carry the whole cookie without being overwhelming.
The filling is what defines this one. It’s that classic cookies & cream-style cream — smooth, slightly sweet, and loaded with small cookie pieces. It adds both flavour and texture, which is important because without it, the cookie would feel a bit one-note.
What works well here is how evenly everything comes together. You’re not getting one bite that’s all cookie and another that’s all cream — it’s balanced all the way through, which is exactly what a sandwich cookie should be.
Texture-wise, you’ve got that soft cookie paired with a slightly thicker, creamy center. It’s not too messy, and it holds together well, which makes it easy to eat without falling apart.
Flavour-wise, it leans more toward the classic cookies & cream profile rather than trying to do anything extra. That works in its favour because it feels familiar and reliable.
It is on the sweeter side, but not in a way that becomes overwhelming quickly. It stays pretty controlled.
Final Verdict:
A solid, well-balanced sandwich cookie that delivers exactly what cookies & cream should be. Simple, but done right.