Crumbl Review: Fudge Brownie Football Cookie
This one is very clearly built around that classic rich brownie profile, just styled differently for the football theme. Going into it, you already expect something dense, chocolate-heavy, and more dessert-like than a traditional cookie.
The base immediately delivers on that expectation. It’s soft, thick, and leans heavily into that brownie texture rather than a cookie. It’s not cakey — it’s more of that slightly dense, fudgy consistency that holds together but still feels soft in every bite.
Flavour-wise, it’s full chocolate right from the start. It doesn’t try to be overly complex — it’s just straight, rich chocolate done well. It’s not bitter, but it also doesn’t lean overly sweet, which keeps it from becoming too heavy too quickly.
The frosting adds another layer of richness. It’s smooth and chocolate-forward, reinforcing the overall flavour rather than changing it. In a lot of cases, doubling up on chocolate like this can become too much, but here it stays pretty controlled.
What makes this cookie work is consistency. Every bite is exactly what you expect — soft, rich, and chocolatey. There’s no real contrast in texture or flavour, but for this style of cookie, that’s not necessarily a downside.
It is on the heavier side, though. This isn’t something you casually snack on — it’s more of a sit-down, dessert-style cookie where a few bites go a long way.
Final Verdict:
A straightforward, rich brownie-style cookie. Not complex, but very solid if you want full chocolate.