Crumbl Review : Peanut Butter Cookie ft Reese’s Pieces
This cookie is exactly what you expect from Crumbl when they do a peanut butter feature — bold, rich, and undeniably peanut-butter-forward. This one doesn’t pretend to be balanced or subtle; it’s a peanut butter lover’s cookie through and through.
The base is incredibly soft and chewy, with that signature dense peanut butter texture that almost resembles the inside of a peanut butter cup. It’s rich, warm, and full-flavoured. From the first bite, you get peanut butter and nothing else — and honestly, that’s the entire point.
The Reese’s Pieces add that crunchy-sweet element to break up the softness. They give pops of chocolate and extra peanut butter flavour, plus the little candy shell crunch, which is a nice contrast. It helps prevent the cookie from feeling too one-note, though the overall flavour is still overwhelmingly peanut butter.
Texture-wise, it holds together well despite being soft. It’s chewy, slightly crumbly in that peanut-butter-cookie way, and thick without being dry. You don’t feel like you’re eating a brick, but it definitely has weight to it.
As for sweetness, it leans slightly sweet but stays true to that saltier, nuttier profile peanut butter lovers prefer. If you’re someone who wants depth, indulgence, and the exact flavour of a Reese’s product turned into a cookie, this is it.
For someone like me who likes peanut butter in moderation, it’s good but heavy. I’d enjoy a few bites, but I wouldn’t want a whole cookie to myself. For hardcore peanut butter fans though? This would absolutely be the highlight of the week.