Crumbl Review: Peanut Butter Cup Brownie (Reese’s)
This one leans even heavier into that dessert category, combining brownie, peanut butter, and Reese’s — so right away, you know it’s going to be rich and very flavour-forward.
The base follows that same brownie-style texture — soft, slightly dense, and fudgy. It sets up a strong chocolate foundation that carries through the entire cookie.
Where this one separates itself is the peanut butter. It’s not subtle at all. It comes through strongly and immediately, which is exactly what you’d expect with Reese’s involved.
The Reese’s pieces add both flavour and texture. You get that familiar peanut butter sweetness mixed with chocolate, and it gives the cookie more dimension compared to a plain brownie base.
The balance here is interesting. The peanut butter is definitely the dominant flavour, but the chocolate base keeps it from feeling one-note. Still, it leans heavily peanut butter forward.
Texture-wise, it’s a mix of soft brownie with slightly firmer candy pieces, which helps break things up just enough.
This is definitely one of those cookies where a little goes a long way. It’s rich, filling, and very flavour-heavy.
Final Verdict:
A very peanut butter-forward brownie cookie. Great if you love Reese’s, but definitely on the heavier side.