Crumbl Review: S’mores Cookie
This one is built around a flavour combination that’s hard to mess up — chocolate, graham, and marshmallow. The real test is whether it actually captures that campfire feel or just ends up being another chocolate cookie.
The base leans into that graham-style cookie, giving it a slightly different flavour from the usual sugar or chocolate base. It’s still soft, but it has a bit more structure and that subtle graham sweetness.
The chocolate comes in strong, whether it’s chunks, drizzle, or both. It adds richness without overwhelming the rest of the cookie, which is important for keeping that s’mores balance.
Then there’s the marshmallow, which is what really defines the cookie. It adds that soft, slightly stretchy texture and a light sweetness that pulls everything together.
When you get all three elements in one bite, it does actually feel pretty close to a s’more. The graham gives it that base, the chocolate adds richness, and the marshmallow softens everything.
Texture is where this cookie stands out. You’ve got soft cookie, melted chocolate, and that slight pull from the marshmallow, which keeps it from feeling repetitive.
It’s still sweet, but it doesn’t feel overly heavy because of how the flavours are balanced.
Final Verdict:
A really solid s’mores cookie that actually delivers on the concept. Balanced, nostalgic, and easy to enjoy.