Crumbl Review: St. Patrick’s Celebration Cake Cookie
This one is very much built around that classic “celebration cake” idea — fun, colourful, and frosting-forward.
Right away, the look gives you exactly what to expect. Bright, festive, covered in frosting and sprinkles — it’s clearly meant to feel like a treat more than anything else.
The base is soft and slightly dense, with a simple vanilla cake-style flavour. It doesn’t try to do too much, and honestly, that’s a good thing because it lets the topping take over.
The frosting is the main feature here. It’s smooth, creamy, and definitely on the sweeter side, but not to the point where it’s overwhelming. It has that classic cake frosting taste — rich, slightly buttery, and very familiar.
The sprinkles don’t add much in terms of flavour, but they do bring a bit of texture and keep it from feeling too flat.
Balance-wise, this cookie leans heavily toward the frosting. If you’re someone who likes more cookie than topping, it might feel a bit one-sided. But if you like that classic cake + icing combo, it hits exactly what you’d expect.
Texture is soft all around — soft cookie, smooth frosting, slight crunch from sprinkles.
This is one of those cookies that’s simple but effective. It’s not trying to be unique, it’s just trying to be enjoyable.
Final Verdict:
A classic cake-style cookie that leans into frosting and fun. Sweet, simple, and exactly what you’d expect from a celebration cookie.