Crumbl Week review August 24-30 2025

🥇 1. Strawberry Cheesecake (Chilled)

Smooth, rich, and easily the standout of the week. The base was silky, the cheesecake frosting tasted like the real thing, and the strawberry layer leaned fresh instead of artificial. A mini was plenty, but as a cheesecake lover, this is one I’d happily grab every week.

🥈 2. Cookies & Cream Milkshake ft. Mini Oreo (Chilled)

Soft, cakey, and balanced with just enough Oreo flavor to feel indulgent. The frosting was perfectly sweet without being too much, and the mini Oreo on top (even if a little soft) tied it together. A cookie I’d definitely buy again.

🥉 3. Milk Chocolate Chip

The classic done right. Crisp on the bottom, soft and chewy inside, with big chunks of smooth milk chocolate. Nothing fancy—just a cookie you could eat every single day without getting tired of it.

4. S’mores

Smelled like the real deal, and the center bite with marshmallow, chocolate, and cookie together was a true “s’mores moment.” The graham got lost and the marshmallow only showed up in a couple bites, but it was still enjoyable enough to have again—just know it’s more cookie than campfire.

5. Chocolate Wafer Bar

Looked like a Kit Kat dream, but the texture didn’t deliver. The chocolate was rich and tasty, but the wafer lost its crunch, leaving the cookie a bit dry and crumbly. A letdown compared to the promise, but not a bad cookie overall.

6. Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip

Rich chocolate base with a chewy, soft texture, but the peanut butter chips left a bit of an artificial aftertaste. Not unpleasant, but not something I’d go out of my way to buy again.

7. Strawberry Pretzel Pie (Chilled)

The most disappointing of the bunch. All strawberry syrup up front, and not much else—the pretzel never really showed up, and the balance just wasn’t there. Thick, heavy, and more of a novelty than something you’d crave again.

⸻

Bottom Line:

This week had a clear winner in Strawberry Cheesecake, with Cookies & Cream and Milk Chocolate Chip rounding out the top tier. The S’mores and Wafer Bar were decent middle picks, while Peanut Butter Chip and Pretzel Pie landed at the bottom. Overall, a solid week, but one where the chilled cheesecake cookie carried the show.

Stay tuned for the recipes for all of these that I’ve created so you can have your favourites every day