Crumbl Weekly Overview Dec 15-21 2025
This week’s lineup leans heavily into holiday flavours and dessert-style cookies, and overall, it’s one of those weeks where the range of textures and formats makes it feel more interesting than the flavours alone.
You’ve got a mix of:
- rich, chocolate-heavy cookies
- creamy, layered desserts
- classic flavour profiles
- and lighter, more playful options
Starting with the strongest performers, the Candy Cane Brownie Cookie stands out right away. It takes a familiar holiday flavour combo and actually balances it properly. The chocolate is rich, the peppermint is controlled, and the brownie texture makes it feel like a full dessert instead of just a cookie.
The Red Velvet Holiday Sandwich Cookie is another top-tier option this week. It’s one of the most balanced cookies overall, with the cream cheese filling and red velvet base working exactly how they should. Nothing feels overpowering, and it actually delivers on the flavour it promises.
Then you have the Eggnog Tres Leches Cake, which is easily the most unique item of the week. It completely steps outside the cookie category and leans into a soft, soaked cake that feels more like a proper dessert. It’s light, smooth, and surprisingly not too heavy despite how rich it sounds.
On the more one-note side, the Peanut Butter Cup Cookie is very specific. If you love peanut butter, it’s going to hit exactly how you want. But if you’re looking for balance with chocolate, it just doesn’t give you that — it’s very peanut butter forward and stays there.
The Cookie That Stole Christmas sits more in the middle. It’s fun, it’s festive, and it’s easy to eat, but it doesn’t stand out in terms of flavour. It’s more of a “nice to have” than a must-get.
What makes this week work is the variety. You’re not stuck with one type of cookie — you’ve got:
- soft and fudgy
- light and creamy
- classic and simple
- rich and indulgent
It gives you options depending on what you’re in the mood for, which is exactly what a good Crumbl week should do.
⭐ Top Picks This Week:
- Candy Cane Brownie Cookie
- Red Velvet Holiday Sandwich Cookie
- Eggnog Tres Leches Cake
⭐ Skip or One-Time Try:
- Peanut Butter Cup Cookie (unless you LOVE peanut butter)
- The Cookie That Stole Christmas (fun, but not standout)
Overall, this week leans more dessert-heavy than cookie-heavy, and that actually works in its favour. It feels seasonal, it feels intentional, and there are enough strong options to make it worth trying.