Review: Crumbl Chocolate Peanut Butter Sandwich
This one is all about balance. Both the chocolate and peanut butter come through clearly, but neither overpowers the other. It’s rich, yes, but not in a cloying way — and unlike some peanut butter desserts, it doesn’t leave behind that weird aftertaste.
The sandwich format gives you a little extra with every bite: smooth, indulgent filling paired with the sturdier cookie layers. It’s definitely one of Crumbl’s richer options, but it feels satisfying instead of overwhelming.
Bottom Line: If you love the classic chocolate–peanut butter combo, this is one of Crumbl’s best renditions. Rich, balanced, and worth the splurge.
✨ Want to try this one at home? I’ll be posting my copycat recipe for it next week. Keep an eye out if you want to recreate the flavor without the drive-thru.