Review: Crumbl Cookies & Cream Milkshake Cookie (ft. Mini Oreo)
The Cookies & Cream Milkshake cookie leans soft from the start. The base is more on the cakey side, which makes it extra light and tender, and then the icing comes in—sweet, fluffy, and almost nostalgic. It’s the kind of frosting that reminds you of Dunkaroos or tub icing: just sweet enough to be fun, but not so sugary it overwhelms the bite (unless you pile too much on).
Oreo flavor runs throughout the cookie, though it’s more subtle than bold. You’ll get hints of that classic cookies-and-cream taste, but it never hits you full-force—until you get to the mini Oreo on top. That little piece feels like the “Oreo moment” of the cookie, even if it was more soft than crisp by the time it sat in the icing. Still, it’s a thoughtful touch that makes the cookie feel complete.
In terms of balance, this one lands really well. It’s sweet without being too much, and you could easily finish a full-size if you’re a cookies-and-cream fan. A mini feels like the perfect in-between—enough to enjoy the flavor without turning it into a full-on dessert overload.
Bottom Line:
Soft, cakey, and perfectly frosted, the Cookies & Cream Milkshake cookie delivers on nostalgia and balance. Not overpowering, but indulgent in the right way—it’s a Crumbl cookie worth coming back for.
Want to make it at home? Next week I’ll be sharing my exclusive copycat recipe for this cookie — Oreo crumbs in the dough, tangy frosting, and even a milkshake twist. Subscribe so you don’t miss it.