Crumbl Review: Cookies & Cream Milkshake Cookie
This one is built more around texture and layering, and that makes a noticeable difference.
Visually, it looks lighter than the cheesecake cookie but still loaded. You can see cookie pieces throughout, and the topping gives it that milkshake-style look.
The first bite is soft with a slight chew.
The cookies & cream flavour comes through immediately — a sweet vanilla base with chocolate cookie pieces mixed in.
What makes this one work is the contrast.
You get:
- soft cookie base
- crunch from cookie pieces
- smooth, creamy topping
That combination keeps the cookie from feeling flat.
The sweetness is still there, but it’s broken up enough that it doesn’t become overwhelming right away.
The flavour stays consistent, but the texture variation keeps it interesting.
Texture:
- soft and slightly chewy base
- crunchy mix-ins
- smooth topping
It’s still a dessert-style cookie, but easier to eat than the heavier options.
Final Verdict:
Sweet, balanced through texture, and easy to eat. A stronger option because it doesn’t feel one-dimensional.