Crumbl Review: S’mores Brownie Cookie

S’mores desserts are always a bit tricky because they’re trying to recreate a very specific experience — graham cracker, chocolate, marshmallow, and that slightly toasted flavour you’d get from a fire. When it works, it’s amazing. When it doesn’t, it just feels like a chocolate dessert with random toppings. This one actually leans closer to the “works” side.

The base of this cookie is where everything starts, and here it leans more brownie than cookie, which already puts it in a good position. That dense, soft, slightly fudgy texture gives it a strong foundation that holds all the other elements together. It’s not dry at all, which is important because s’mores desserts need that soft, almost melty texture to feel authentic.

The chocolate flavour is rich but not overpowering. It gives you that classic s’mores chocolate taste without leaning too dark or too sweet. It sits right in the middle, which allows the other elements — especially the marshmallow — to come through.

The marshmallow is a key part of any s’mores dessert, and here it adds that soft, slightly gooey texture that makes the cookie feel more dynamic. It’s not overly sticky or messy, but it brings that light, airy contrast to the dense brownie base.

The graham element adds just enough structure and flavour to tie everything together. It gives a slight crunch and that familiar honey-like flavour that makes s’mores taste like s’mores. Without it, the cookie would just feel like a chocolate dessert, but with it, you get that full combination.

What I like most about this cookie is that it doesn’t overcomplicate things. It sticks to the core flavours and executes them well. It doesn’t try to add too many extras or turn it into something completely different.

This is definitely one of the more enjoyable “fun” cookies in the lineup. It has a bit of everything — texture, flavour contrast, and that nostalgic s’mores feel — without becoming messy or overwhelming.

Final Verdict:

A well-balanced s’mores cookie with a fudgy brownie base, soft marshmallow, and just enough graham flavour to tie it all together. Fun, nostalgic, and done right.